Foresight Nanotech Institute Logo
Image of nano

The other half of nanotech

As I pointed out in Nanotechnology Without Engines, nanotechnology’s promise of being a revolutionary rather than evolutionary technology was based on two key ideas:

Nanotechnology, the revolutionary technology, was always about the power of self-replication and never only about the very small.

This was clearly the case both in Drexler’s conception and in Feynman’s:

… along Feynman’s pathway to nanotechnology, manipulating things at the atomic scale is the last thing you do.

Instead, you start with a desktop system capable of replicating itself and make smaller and smaller copies.

With this in mind, consider the RepRap:
RepRap version 1
(see also the Wikipedia entry)

RepRap’s impact on the pathway to desktop nanofactories has been analyzed in a recent post by Chris Phoenix over at CRN.

A recent Register article notes

Next month will see a new version of the self-replicating RepRap machine, but owners of the existing model won’t need to buy a replacement – they’ll just be able to just print themselves an upgraded version.

Rep-rap 2
(RepRap version 2)

Now in fact RepRap is not fully self-replicating. To begin with, it only makes parts and a human has to assemble the parts to have a new RepRap. And secondly, it can only make about half its own parts. But this does mean that it is autogenous — it includes a productive strange loop. You could consider RepRap a self-replicating machine in an environment where its “feedstock” consisted of nuts, bolts, threaded rods, motors, computers, and human tinkerers in addition to plastic filament. Unfortunately, the environment does not contain these things (especially the tinkerers) in a graduated series of sizes down to the atomic scale.

RepRap2 is oddly reminiscent of the fabricator in my Architectural Considerations for Self-replicating Manufacturing Systems paper. (Nanotechnology 10 323-330)

fabricator

That paper shows what would be necessary to extend something like RepRap, acting as the fabricator, into a system capable of being a starting point on a Feynman pathway to nanotech.

“It is rather a difficult program, but it is a possibility.”

Leave a Reply